5.11 Tactical vs. First Tactical: A Comprehensive Gear Comparison

5.11 Tactical vs First Tactical: Which Brand Is Best for Your Gear?

When it comes to tactical gear, two brands consistently come up in conversation: 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical. Both companies are known for producing high-quality, durable gear that's designed to meet the demanding needs of military personnel, law enforcement, first responders, and outdoor enthusiasts. But which one is the better choice for your tactical needs? In this detailed comparison, we’ll break down the history, innovation, durability, and pricing of both brands to help you decide which one aligns with your specific requirements.

The Origins of 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical

5.11 Tactical has a well-established presence in the tactical gear market. Launched in 2003, the company began with the creation of durable tactical pants that were favored by FBI agents and law enforcement officers for their comfort, versatility, and rugged construction. The company has since expanded its product line to include outerwear, tactical boots, bags, holsters, pouches, and more. Over the years, 5.11 Tactical has become a household name in the tactical world, recognized for its dedication to quality, functionality, and durability.

In contrast, First Tactical is a newer player in the market but has quickly gained a strong following since its inception in 2015. Founded by Dan Costa, who was also one of the original founders of 5.11 Tactical, First Tactical builds on Costa’s decades of experience in the industry. The brand prides itself on producing gear that is field-tested by professionals, with constant input from law enforcement officers, military personnel, and first responders. By focusing on the needs and feedback of their users, First Tactical has positioned itself as an innovator in the field, bringing fresh ideas and designs to the market.

Material & Durability: Which Brand Stands Stronger?

Both 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical take pride in the durability of their gear, but they approach it in different ways.

5.11 Tactical has a reputation for using heavy-duty materials that stand up to extreme conditions. One of their most famous features is their ripstop fabric, which is designed to resist tearing and fraying, even in the harshest environments. Whether you're trekking through dense forests, engaged in urban combat, or participating in search-and-rescue missions, 5.11 gear is built to last. Additionally, their products often feature reinforced stitching, added layers in high-wear areas, and water-resistant coatings, ensuring that their gear won’t give out when you need it most.

First Tactical also boasts impressive durability but with a focus on lightweight efficiency. One of their standout innovations is their laser-cut webbing, which eliminates the need for traditional MOLLE webbing while reducing the overall weight of the gear. This innovation allows for enhanced functionality without compromising strength. First Tactical’s products are made with double-stitched seams, waterproof materials, and abrasion-resistant panels, making them more than capable of enduring the wear and tear of daily tactical operations. Their dedication to field-testing ensures that every piece of gear performs under pressure.

Product Range and Innovation

When it comes to product variety, 5.11 Tactical has a wider range of options. Their catalog includes everything from tactical pants and combat boots to backpacks, pouches, tactical knives, and outerwear. The brand is known for its ability to innovate and adapt its products for a broad range of environments and needs. Many of 5.11's products incorporate unique features like hidden compartments, self-healing zippers, and moisture-wicking fabrics that make their gear more comfortable and functional. Their constant refinement of designs has helped them maintain their position as one of the top brands in the tactical industry.

On the other hand, First Tactical may not have the same breadth of products as 5.11, but what they lack in variety, they make up for in user-driven innovation. First Tactical is a brand that takes direct feedback from professionals seriously. For instance, their Tactix System Jackets allow wearers to customize their layers based on weather and operational requirements, giving professionals better adaptability in the field. Their Advanced Knee Pad System, built into their tactical pants, offers unparalleled comfort and protection without adding unnecessary bulk. This level of fine-tuned detail is a hallmark of First Tactical’s commitment to delivering gear that excels in real-world scenarios.

Comfort & Fit: Which Brand Excels?

For those who spend long hours on the job, comfort is just as important as durability. Both 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical prioritize comfort in their designs, but they approach it differently.

5.11 Tactical is known for its ergonomic designs that allow for full mobility without sacrificing toughness. Many of their pants and outerwear are made with stretch fabrics, offering flexibility where it’s needed most. Whether it’s the waistband of their tactical pants or the shoulder seams of their jackets, 5.11 makes sure that their gear doesn’t restrict movement, making it ideal for users who need to run, climb, or crouch at a moment’s notice.

First Tactical takes a slightly more focused approach to comfort. Their designs often incorporate mesh paneling for breathability, articulated elbows for better arm movement, and adjustable waistbands for a more tailored fit. For professionals who need high-performance gear that can be worn all day, these small adjustments can make a big difference. First Tactical's attention to detail ensures that their gear not only fits well but also enhances your ability to perform during long, grueling operations.

Pricing and Value: Getting the Best Bang for Your Buck

In terms of pricing, 5.11 Tactical covers a broader spectrum. While they offer some premium-priced products designed for specialized operations, they also have a range of more affordable options for casual users or those who don’t need the highest level of tactical gear. This range of pricing makes 5.11 Tactical more accessible to a wider audience, including both professional users and enthusiasts.

First Tactical generally offers more competitive pricing. Despite its focus on innovation and high-quality materials, First Tactical gear tends to be priced slightly lower than comparable products from 5.11. For users who want affordable tactical gear without sacrificing innovation, First Tactical presents a compelling option. Their balance of cost and functionality makes them an attractive choice for those on a budget who still want professional-grade gear.

So, Which Brand Should You Choose?

Ultimately, the decision between 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical comes down to your personal needs and preferences.

  • Choose 5.11 Tactical if you’re looking for a brand with an extensive product line, a long-standing reputation for durability, and gear that has been tried and tested by countless law enforcement and military professionals.
  • Choose First Tactical if you want innovative, user-driven designs that focus on comfort, lightweight efficiency, and affordable pricing without compromising on quality.

Shop Tactical Gear at Tac Essentials

At Tac Essentials, we carry a wide selection of both 5.11 Tactical and First Tactical gear, so you can find the products that best suit your operational needs. Whether you're looking for tactical pants, boots, or outerwear, we've got you covered. Browse our collections and gear up today:

Watch our in-depth 5.11 Tactical vs First Tactical comparison on YouTube: Tac Essentials YouTube Channel


For more updates, product comparisons, and gear reviews, follow us on social media:
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/tacessentials/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61556074643393

Key Takeaways:

  • 5.11 Tactical has a long history and wide product range, offering durability and versatility across their line.
  • First Tactical focuses on user feedback, lightweight designs, and innovative features.
  • Durability: 5.11 emphasizes heavy-duty materials, while First Tactical focuses on efficient, field-tested designs.
  • Price: 5.11 offers a broad price range, while First Tactical often provides premium features at a lower price point.
  • Comfort: Both brands excel, but First Tactical’s user-driven adjustments offer tailored comfort for long-term wear.

Which brand suits your needs best? Find out at tacessentials.com today!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.